Misleading

Steam train moving through snow from Germany shared as Himachal Pradesh.


The viral video of a steam train moving through snow is from Germany’s Harz region, not Himachal Pradesh.

A lovely scene of a train whizzing through the snow, with white frosty trees on both side and steam billowing from its engine is going viral on social media. The users who share believe it is from Himachal Pradesh. Erik Solheim, the former Minister of Climate and the Environment of Norway, shared the video with a caption: “Incredible India. Fairyland Himachal.” 

Archive Link

Fact Check

A simple reverse image search on Google using the key frames of the viral video led us to a Facebook post on the German life page featuring a similar train moving through snow-capped trees with the caption, “Hogwarts express! Who wants to join?  Nationalpark Harz, Germany”

With this clue, we searched further and discovered a 2017 YouTube video titled “With the Brocken Railway through the Harz Mountains.” Contains the visuals almost same as the viral video.

We discovered more about this train and location from the travel blog Destination the World. According to the blog “Brocken is with its 1142m the highest peak and is located in the Harz National Park (Nationalpark Harz). This is also the highest mountain in northern Germany. The Harz Mountian Railway or Trans-Harz Railway (Harzquerbahn) is a 140km narrow-gauge rail network, the largest in Germany, served by 25 steam trains at 10 diesel locomotives. The three Harz narrow-gauge railways – the Harzquerbahn, the Brockenbahn and the Selketalbahn – which move along a route only one metre wide and represent the largest narrow-gauge network in Germany, originally served to transport goods. Today they are used for tourist purposes and attract almost one million people a year with their nostalgic appearance. 

We also discovered a Guardian report published on 1 February 2023 commemorating the 125th anniversary of steam trains operating in Germany’s Harz Mountains. According to the report, the “Brocken line” is part of a wide network of narrow-gauge railways that operate in the eastern half of the Harz region. Brocken is the highest summit in the Harz Mountains at 1,142 metres above sea level. The report also carried a photo of the maroon-yellow train that looked similar to the one in the viral video.

Though Himachal Pradesh has beautiful train rides through snow-covered hills on the Kalka Shimla railway track, this viral video is from Germany.

Conclusion

Fact Crescendo found the claim made along with the viral video to be Misleading. The viral video of a steam train moving through snow is from Germany’s Harz region, not Himachal Pradesh.

Title:Steam train moving through snow from Germany shared as Himachal Pradesh.

Fact Check By: Usha Manoj

Result: Misleading


Usha Manoj

Recent Posts

Tamil Nadu School girls threw away their dupatta in protest of school uniform-viral claim is misleading

Students threw their dupatta as a welcome gesture to Geetha Illangovan [author of Dupatta Podunga…

17 hours ago

Unrelated images shared as items recovered from ED raid at Lalu Prasad Yadav’s residence

The images are unrelated to the raids on the residences of former Railway Minister Lalu…

3 days ago

EXPLAINED: Will Putin Be Arrested As ICC Issues Warrant Over War Crimes in Ukraine?

It is highly unlikely that the ICC will be able to take any action against…

3 days ago

2015 video from Nepal shared as recent New Zealand Earthquake 

The viral video shows a “mini tsunami” in a hotel swimming pool during the massive…

4 days ago

Scripted Video Shared as Muslim Man In a Burqa Caught While Attempting to Kidnap a Hindu Child…

A video of a man catching a kidnapper guised in a Burqa is going viral…

4 days ago

Postage stamp of PM Modi issued by Turkey government is viral with misleading claim

The Turkish government issued a commemorative postage stamp for all leaders who attended the G20…

6 days ago